|Friends Of The Little Bighorn Battlefield||
The Next Generation In The Study Of Custer's Last Stand
Was Custer A Psychopath?
|• The Battle • Archeology • Memorials • Little Bighorn Store • News • Book Reviews|
Commentary by Bob Reece
“Custer was a psychopath which always gives you a leg-up; makes you more active and more imaginative in your strategies… So, Custer goes to the Senate, he says, ‘there is gold, there is gold in them thar hills.’”
David Milch, Executive Producer, Creator/Writer Of HBO's “Deadwood”
Photo courtesy National Archives
The HBO series, “Deadwood”, was released on DVD today, February 8, 2005. I love that show. I looked forward to each Sunday evening and the next show in the series to see what happened next to Seth Bullock or Calamity Jane or to find out how much longer Wild Bill had to live.
From the get go, from the opening scene of the first show, which was directed by the all-time great western film director Walter Hill, I was hooked. The writing is crisp, original, Shakespearean, and better than most theatrical films.
I’m coming from a place where I don’t watch television shows, sitcoms, or whatever you want to call them. What little time I give to TV is spent watching documentaries on Discovery, History Channel, and such. So, a drama has to be good to get me to watch it.
Needless to say, I was looking forward to “Deadwood” finally available on DVD. It is a great DVD; all the episodes from the first season are available. However, I was shocked when I saw and heard Mr. Milch make the above comment about Custer in one of the extra features on the DVD.
Shocked for many reasons. I figured this guy knew his history – he captured it so well in the series. But, it appears that Mr. Milch has become caught-up with the stereotypes of the 1870s West, especially with Custer. Why is it no one in Hollywood really understands Custer? Did Mr. Milch feel he needed to make such a comment about Custer to add to the drama of the DVD? Does he really believe what he said? If he does, then he needs to be set straight.
Custer was no psychopath. Ted Bundy was a psychopath. Hitler was a psychopath. Custer did not need to be a psychopath in order to be more imaginative. If he did, then so did Picasso, but Picasso wasn’t psycho either.
Custer has become the scapegoat for all the ills committed against the American Indian during the 19th century. And, that is wrong. Custer is accused of the slaughter of innocent Indian women and children. That is completely inaccurate.
Custer successfully attacked only one Indian village in his military career on the western plains. Before the Battle of the Washita, Custer told his officers and soldiers not to shoot and kill the women and children. One of his captains, Benteen, tried his best to avoid killing a young Indian boy. In that moment, Benteen kept moving and dodging around a tree between himself and the boy as the Indian continued to fire upon him. In the end, Benteen was forced to kill the boy to save his own life.
At the end of the Battle of the Washita, Custer left the village with over 50 noncombatant Indians as prisoners. He ordered his soldiers to retrieve two Indian ponies, from the village herd, for each woman prisoner for their ride back north. That is an odd way for a man to act that is psycho and loves to kill Indian women and children.
Custer did not go before the U.S. Senate advising them that there was gold in the Black Hills of South Dakota. Instead, Custer was ordered to go to the Black Hills by his boss, the U.S. Government, to establish a fort there. It was rumored that gold may be there, so it was searched out and discovered – the rest is history.
So, Mr. Milch, I hope that you might be open-minded enough to question your statement about Custer and take the time to read your history, a little better. You will discover that Custer was more complex than you could ever imagine, and you will realize that your calling him "a psychopath" was just plain wrong.
In the meantime, I look forward to the second season of “Deadwood” beginning Sunday, March 6 (Alamo Day), 2005 on HBO.
Copyright 1999-2013 Bob Reece
Friends Little Bighorn Battlefield, P.O. Box 636, Crow Agency, MT 59022